Harmen Otten
05 October 2026
Harmen Otten
05 October 2026
Imagine a company builds a solar park because it is commercially attractive and would be profitable even without carbon credits. Should that project then be able to receive carbon credits and sell them to companies that want to offset their residual emissions? For most people, the answer intuitively feels like: probably not.
Yet this question touches on one of the most important principles in the voluntary carbon market: additionality. Additionality determines whether a climate project genuinely delivers additional climate impact, or whether the emission reduction would also have taken place without carbon credits. As such, the concept forms the basis of almost every carbon credit issued today.
A climate project is additional when the emission reduction or carbon removal it achieves would not have taken place without the income from carbon credits. In other words: the carbon credits make the project possible or speed up its implementation.
If a project already has a viable business case without carbon credits, or is already required by law, its climate impact is not additional. In that case, buyers of carbon credits are not financing any additional climate benefit, but an activity that would have happened anyway.
That is why additionality is often seen as one of the most important quality criteria in the voluntary carbon market.
Organisations buy carbon credits because they want to take responsibility for emissions they cannot yet avoid today. By investing in carbon credits, they support climate projects that reduce emissions or remove CO2 from the atmosphere. This only works if the underlying climate impact is genuinely additional.
Imagine a project reduces CO2 emissions by 10,000 tonnes a year. Based on this reduction, the project generates carbon credits, which are then sold to companies that want to offset their residual emissions. If that emission reduction would also have happened without carbon credits, buying these credits does not create any additional climate benefit. After all, the reduction was already planned, or economically attractive enough to go ahead on its own.
Ultimately, nothing then changes in the amount of CO2 that is reduced or removed worldwide. An organisation thinks it is offsetting its emissions, while in reality no additional impact is being made. You could say that in this case, carbon credits lose their function as a financing mechanism for climate solutions and end up as little more than trading in hot air.
That is precisely why additionality is so important in the voluntary carbon market. Carbon credits are, after all, intended to make possible projects that would not get off the ground, or would struggle to, without the income from credits.
That sounds simpler than it is in practice. After all, nobody can directly prove what would have happened if carbon credits had not existed. That is why standards such as Verra, Gold Standard, Puro.earth and SNK use various tests to demonstrate that additionality is plausible. These look at aspects such as:
financial barriers
technical barriers
legal requirements
common market practice
Different forms of additionality are considered. For example, if an activity is already required by law, it will generally not be considered additional. The same often applies to techniques or practices that are already widely used and seen as common practice within a sector. If almost all companies in a sector already apply a certain measure, for instance, it is harder to demonstrate that a project genuinely delivers additional climate impact through carbon credits.
It can also be examined whether a project already has a viable business case without income from carbon credits. If a project is economically attractive enough to be carried out on its own, that may indicate that carbon credits are not necessary for its implementation.
The more evidence there is that a project is not legally required, is not yet common practice and needs support to be realised, the stronger its additionality case is generally considered to be.
In recent years, additionality has become a major topic in the voluntary carbon market. This is partly because several project types have come under fire in the media and in studies by scientists, journalists and rating agencies. These regularly raised the question of whether certain emission reductions actually depended on income from carbon credits.
For some solar and hydropower projects, for example, the question is whether they would also have been built without income from carbon credits. In many countries, these technologies have already become economically attractive or are supported in other ways.
At the same time, new climate solutions are constantly emerging that do depend heavily on additional financing. Think of biochar, direct air capture or circular innovations that struggle to get off the ground because they have to compete with virgin raw materials.
Precisely because organisations invest in carbon credits voluntarily, they want to be sure that their investment genuinely delivers additional climate impact. Companies want to take responsibility for their residual emissions, but at the same time avoid being associated with projects whose climate impact is in question.
That is why additionality is more central than ever in discussions about project quality, integrity and greenwashing risks in the voluntary carbon market. For many buyers, the question is no longer just how much CO2 a project avoids or removes, but above all whether that climate impact would also have happened without carbon credits.
No. A project can have a very large climate impact and at the same time a weak additionality case. Conversely, a relatively small project can be highly additional. Additionality therefore says nothing about how much CO2 is avoided or removed. It says something about whether that climate impact actually depends on income from carbon credits. That is why professional buyers usually look not only at additionality, but also at factors such as:
emission reduction or carbon removal
permanence (storage duration)
verification
monitoring
biodiversity
social impact
Additionality is therefore an important quality criterion, but certainly not the only one.
The voluntary carbon market is developing rapidly. Organisations are setting ever higher standards for the quality of carbon credits and are increasingly asking for independent assessments of projects. In this development, additionality remains a central concept.
When organisations buy carbon credits, they want certainty that their investment genuinely contributes to additional climate impact. Additionality is one of the most important building blocks for this.
It also explains why projects with comparable emission reductions are sometimes assessed very differently. The question is not only how much CO2 is saved or removed, but also whether that climate impact would have happened without carbon finance.
For organisations that want to use carbon credits, additionality is an important point of attention when selecting projects. It is wise to look at:
the certification standard used
the project’s additionality analysis
independent ratings
the financial and technical context in which the project operates
Ultimately, a carbon credit represents more than one tonne of CO2. The underlying question is whether that tonne of CO2 genuinely represents additional climate impact.
That is exactly what additionality is about.
ORCA offers carbon credits from projects with a strong additionality case and demonstrable climate impact.
Harmen Otten
Co-Founder