Why does one carbon credit cost €5 and another €250?

Harmen Otten

26 October 2026

Discover which factors determine the price, and why quality often matters more than going for the cheapest option.

Anyone looking into carbon credits for the first time often comes across the same question. Why does one carbon credit cost just a few euros per tonne of CO2, while more than €250 per tonne is paid for other projects?

At first glance, this price difference seems hard to explain. After all, a carbon credit always represents one tonne of CO2 equivalent. Yet prices on the voluntary carbon market can differ by tens or even hundreds of euros. The answer does not lie in the amount of CO2, but in the way the climate impact is achieved, measured and safeguarded.

Not every tonne of CO2 is the same

Anyone who looks at market data from the voluntary carbon market will immediately see that there is no such thing as the price of a carbon credit. According to market research by Ecosystem Marketplace, carbon credit prices vary widely depending on project type, geographical location and the perceived quality of the underlying climate impact. While some large-scale emission reduction projects are traded for less than €10 per tonne of CO2, high-quality carbon removals can cost hundreds of euros per tonne.

These price differences have only widened in recent years. Whereas the market used to be largely driven by volume and cost reduction, buyers today increasingly look at aspects such as additionality, durability of the climate impact, independent verification and long-term storage of CO2. Based on market analyses and price data from the voluntary carbon market, the following indicative price levels can be distinguished:

Project type

Indicative price

Large-scale emission reduction projects

€2 - €10

High-quality reduction and avoidance projects

€10 - €30

European carbon credits

€20 - €40

Biochar and other removals

€100+

Direct Air Capture and mineralisation

€200 - €850+

These price ranges should not be seen as fixed market prices. There are considerable differences between projects within each category. They do, however, illustrate how broad the price spectrum within the voluntary carbon market has become.

Why were carbon credits so cheap for so many years?

To understand today’s market, it is important to look at its history. For many years, the voluntary carbon market was dominated by large-scale emission reduction projects. Renewable energy projects in particular generated large volumes of credits at relatively low cost. At the same time, a considerable surplus of credits built up in some segments of the market, which pushed prices down even further. This created the impression that a carbon credit should always be cheap. That impression is now changing rapidly.

Quality is becoming increasingly important

In recent years, companies have become more critical of the quality of carbon credits. Initiatives and rating agencies such as ICVCM, BeZero and Sylvera, along with SBTi’s stricter requirements, have made the following factors increasingly important:

  • additionality

  • independent verification

  • monitoring

  • transparency

  • risk of reversal

  • long-term climate impact

As a result, the market is increasingly shifting from a focus on volume to a focus on quality. The question is no longer just how many tonnes of CO2 are claimed, but also how robustly that climate impact is substantiated.

Why are carbon removals so much more expensive?

The biggest price differences often arise between emission reduction projects and carbon removals. There is a logical reason for this. A project that reduces methane leaks or recycles plastic prevents emissions from occurring. A carbon removal project, on the other hand, has to actually extract CO2 from the atmosphere and store it for the long term. This often requires:

  • advanced technology

  • extensive monitoring

  • rigorous verification

  • higher development costs

Supply is also limited. That is why removal prices are often considerably higher than those of traditional emission reduction projects.

Why price differences are likely to widen further

Price differences within the voluntary carbon market are expected to widen further in the coming years.

On the one hand, there continues to be a large supply of traditional emission reduction projects. On the other hand, demand for high-quality carbon removals is growing strongly, driven in part by developments such as SBTi 2.0 and the increasing focus on permanent carbon removal.

At the same time, the supply of removals is still limited. New techniques such as biochar, mineralisation and direct air capture are still at a relatively early stage of market development. This is causing different segments of the carbon market to drift further and further apart.

While some credits may remain available at a few euros per tonne, high-quality removals could command significantly higher prices for years to come.

Why the cheapest carbon credit is not always the best choice

When organisations compare carbon credits, it seems obvious to look at the price per tonne of CO2. Yet that price only tells part of the story. A more important question is: what climate impact does the organisation want to achieve?

A low-cost credit can fit an organisation’s goals perfectly well. At the same time, low prices can sometimes be linked to uncertainty about a project’s actual climate impact. In recent years, there has been considerable debate within the voluntary carbon market about issues such as additionality, monitoring, permanence and whether emission reductions have actually been achieved.

That is precisely why more and more buyers look not only at price, but also at the quality and integrity of a project. Factors such as independent verification, transparency, robust monitoring and the extent to which climate impact is actually demonstrated all play an important role.

In addition, more expensive projects can offer extra value in the form of longer storage duration, greater certainty about the emission reduction or removal achieved, and additional social or environmental benefits.

Ultimately, choosing carbon credits is not about buying the cheapest tonne of CO2, but about deciding what contribution an organisation wants to make to the climate. Anyone who wants to make a real impact will need to look beyond the price per credit.

Is a low-cost carbon credit bad by definition?

Although low prices can sometimes point to uncertainty about a project’s quality or integrity, price alone does not tell the whole story. There are also budget-friendly carbon credits that meet high quality standards and deliver demonstrable climate impact.

After all, the price of a carbon credit is determined not only by quality, but also by factors such as project location, scale and market conditions. Large-scale projects can benefit from economies of scale, while projects in certain regions have lower development and operating costs. As a result, high-quality credits can sometimes be offered at relatively attractive prices.

For buyers, it is therefore important not to look at price alone, but also at the underlying quality. More and more organisations assess projects on criteria such as additionality, independent verification and external quality assessments. Examples include the CCP label from the Integrity Council for the Voluntary Carbon Market (ICVCM) and independent ratings from agencies such as BeZero and Sylvera.

At ORCA, we see in practice that both budget-friendly and premium carbon credits can meet high quality standards. Even in lower price segments, projects are available that hold a CCP label or strong independent ratings, for example.

The challenge lies not so much in finding the cheapest credit, but in putting together a portfolio that matches an organisation’s goals and available budget.

Frequently asked questions about carbon credit prices

That depends on the project type, quality and location. Prices range roughly from a few euros per tonne of CO2 to hundreds of euros per tonne for high-quality carbon removals. Factors such as additionality, storage duration, verification and market demand have a major influence on the final price.

Carbon removals actively extract CO2 from the atmosphere and store it for the long term. This generally requires more technology, monitoring, verification and investment than emission reduction projects. In addition, the supply of high-quality removals is still limited, while demand is growing.

Often they are, but that does not mean Dutch carbon credits are expensive by definition. Dutch projects generally have higher development and operating costs than many international projects, which places them on average at the higher end of the price spectrum. At the same time, there are also Dutch projects that are priced relatively affordably thanks to economies of scale. Through ORCA, for example, organisations can invest in Dutch carbon credits that deliver local climate impact at prices that compete well with many other high-quality projects. A number of organisations deliberately choose Dutch carbon credits because, in addition to climate impact, they value local visibility, transparency and engagement. Choosing Dutch carbon credits is therefore often not just a question of price, but also a choice for the type of impact an organisation wants to achieve.

No. Price does not tell you everything about the quality of a project. There are both budget-friendly and premium carbon credits that meet high quality standards. Factors such as additionality, independent verification, risks, storage duration and external quality assessments are often more important than price alone.

Because not all projects are the same. The market shows major differences in technology, risk, storage duration, location, scale and quality. Supply and demand also play an important role. As a result, prices can range from a few euros to hundreds of euros per tonne of CO2.

The largest price differences are usually caused by the project type. Carbon removals are generally much more expensive than emission reduction or avoidance projects, due to their higher costs and limited availability. Factors such as location, scale, certification and market developments also affect the price.

Yes. Many organisations opt for a portfolio approach that combines different types of projects. For example, high-quality permanent carbon removals can be combined with carefully selected emission reduction or avoidance projects. This often creates a good balance between budget, risk diversification and climate impact. It also allows organisations to contribute to several types of climate solutions at the same time.
 
 

Looking for the right balance between price and impact?

We help organisations select carbon credits that fit their climate goals, risk profile and budget.

Harmen Otten

Co-Founder